The odds of two kickers from the same highschool kicking for the same team as described above, based on amount of teams in the league, states in question that produce football talent, number of schools in those states, past probabilities of occurences being met, percent deviations, trim and shielded % chance yield a number far greater than the 1 million to 1 dart that was tossed out in the article.

I calculate the chance occurence to be 32.89 million to 1.